Reviews
State Farm® Agent Shane Steimel
Our customers are the center of our universe and we're grateful for them.
If you're willing to share your experience about your interaction with our agency, it'll be a great help for other people looking to make smart and confident decisions about their insurance and financial services.
Leave us a review
Get a quote today
What our customers say about us...
Bonnie Walker
October 30, 2026
"Shane Steimel’s office is top notch to handle your insurance needs. Mick was very friendly and very professional, and Shane reached out to follow up"
"Thank you so much for taking your time and share your experience with Shane Steimel State Farm, Bonnie! We appreciate the feedback, and are glad to know that we hit the mark with being both welcoming and professional. "
Sade Sparks
October 26, 2026
"My current State Farm agent referred me to Shane while I'm preparing for an out-of-state relocation. What I expected to be a routine task turned out to be a genuinely positive transition. I thought the best way to describe my experience was through his name:
S – Simplicity: Shane explained my coverage options clearly, made the process easy to understand, and welcomed my (many) questions.
H – Honesty: Shane offered straightforward guidance, answered my questions candidly, and helped me understand the considerations behind his recommendations. That transparency extended to his team. When an unexpected policy timing restriction arose, Mick from the office reached out (at least twice) to explain the situation, offer a practical remedy, and ask how I preferred to proceed before making any billing adjustments.
A – Anticipatory: I especially appreciated Shane's timeliness and proactive approach. From coordinating with my existing agent to arranging for proof of insurance to be provided to my new apartment community, he stayed ahead of the details and kept me informed without requiring me to follow up or remember what needed to happen next. He also brought up other insurance considerations I hadn't thought to ask about, including long-term disability coverage, which helped me recognize the impact of the gap in my employment benefits.
N – No pressure: Shane was equally thoughtful about what could reasonably wait, considering my circumstances and preferences rather than encouraging unnecessary coverage or immediate decisions. Considering all that I'm juggling, I appreciated having the space to make informed choices without feeling like I was being pressured and sold something.
E – Engaging: Our exchanges were informative and genuinely enjoyable. Shane was personable, approachable, and professional, making the experience feel more conversational than transactional.
If you're considering Shane's office for your insurance needs, I'd encourage you to give him a shot and let him handle it for you!"
"Wow! Thank you so much for such a thoughtful and detailed review, Sade! I truly appreciate the time you took to share your experience, and I especially enjoyed the creative use of my name!
It was a pleasure getting to know you and helping make your transition to Noblesville a little easier. Moving comes with plenty of challenges, and I'm glad Mick and I could help take a few things off your plate. Our goal is always to provide straightforward guidance, answer questions honestly, and help people make informed decisions without pressure.
Thank you again for trusting our office with your insurance needs. We look forward to working with you for years to come, and I wish you all the best as you settle into your new Hamilton County home!"
Brandi Riemersma
October 26, 2026
"Shane and his team are amazing and super professional!"
"We appreciate you taking the time to share your experience, Brandi! It's a pleasure to help, and we're glad you were happy with the insurance service at Shane Steimel State Farm."
Mindy Aguilera
October 16, 2026
"Very fast service, clear and direct communication. I love my agent going straight to the point!"
"Thank you so much for the 5-star review, Mindy! Nice to know we were able to hit the mark with our communication and service - we know that it is important you have what you need to make informed decisions...and that we work on your timeline! We appreciate you choosing Shane Steimel State Farm for your insurance needs. We'll look for to the next time we can be of assistance."
sophia galka
September 10, 2026
"Made the process very simple!!"
"Thanks for the 5-star review, Sophia! We're so glad that we were able to help make the process simple, and that we are your choice agency for State Farm insurance in Hamilton County. We look forward to the next time we can help!"
Kylene Toney
September 4, 2026
"Great to work with, excellent communication and honest with updated rates! Highly recommend!"
"We are so glad you shared your feedback - thank you for the awesome review, Kylene! We take pride in our communication and helping clients get the very best value on the insurance coverage that fits their preferences. We look forward to working with you at Shane Steimel State Farm for years to come!"
Susan Hendricks
July 24, 2026
"working with James Tomlin in the office was a breeze, he just made everything easy"
"Thank you, Susan! I'm delighted to hear that working with Mick has helped make your insurance experience a breeze! Mick is committed to providing friendly and timely service, and it's wonderful to know that you appreciate his efforts. If you ever need anything else, just let us know. Thanks for choosing Shane Steimel State Farm!"
Loren Welker
July 24, 2026
"State Farm Agent Shane Steimel was very helpful in getting my insurance needs taken care of and he explained all my questions in detail. I really appreciate that he took the time to go over all my concerns and questions."
"Thank you for the wonderful review, Loren! I'm really happy to hear that our approach of helping provide explanations and offering options allowed you to have a better understanding of what works for your family insurance needs. We look forward to working with you for years to come! Please let us know anytime if you have any concerns or questions. Thanks again for choosing Shane Steimel State Farm in Noblesville."
Matt Harter
June 30, 2026
"Shane and his team are always on top of my needs. If it’s adding, removing or a claim they respond immediately and make sure I am taken care of. Would definitely recommend them to anyone looking for any insurance needs!"
"Thank you so much for 5-star review, Matt! We value the feedback you shared for Shane Steimel State Farm and truly appreciate the trust you have in us as your Noblesville insurance provider. We'll continue to be mindful of top-level customer service...with timely communication and clear explanations. Thanks again!"
Fe
June 29, 2026
"UPDATE: Still with Shane and still incredibly happy. He makes everything easy and quick. I would never even think of going elsewhere. Not only the greatest insurance guy but also just a truly kind and decent human being. Customer for life!!
I can’t say enough great things about Shane Steimel from State Farm! From the moment we first spoke, Shane was incredibly personable and easy to talk to. He made what could have been a confusing and stressful process feel simple and completely manageable. He took the time to walk us through every detail of the different options, answered all our questions with patience, and ensured we understood exactly what we were getting. It’s rare to find someone so genuinely committed to both their clients and their craft. This feels more like a personal relationship than a business one and that's exactly what we were looking for. If you’re looking for an agent who truly cares and makes insurance feel less intimidating, Shane is your guy!"
"Thank you so much for your kind words! We're thrilled to hear that you had such a positive experience working with Shane Steimel State Farm. We're especially happy to know you felt welcomed, appropriately educated and empowered to choose from options that fit your priorities. We truly appreciate your recommendation and look forward to continuing to support your insurance needs!
"
Jeff Mahoney
June 19, 2026
"Have worked with Shane and Mic for several years. They are awesome!"
"Thank you so much for the awesome review, Jeff! Your trust in working with Shane Steimel State Farm through the year means the world to us. We're glad that we've been able to leverage our insurance experience to help with recommendations for your family needs in Noblesville. If we can be of further help, just let us know!"
Alina Maiers
May 6, 2026
"Shane is nothing short of professional and knowledgeable! Willing to go above and beyond. Helped me on a Personal Articles Policy and could not be happier with the help!"
"Thank you so much for the terrific review, Alina! We're thrilled that we have been a good working partner for your insurance needs. If there is anything else we can do for you - please let us know!"
jordan reese
April 21, 2026
"Shane was great to work with. I moved to Indiana from out of state and made the transition easy to acquire insurance. Gave me options and ideas without pushing it on me. Thanks for your work and taking care of me, Shane!"
"Thank you for sharing your experience and the awesome review, Jordan! We're so glad you gave us a chance to earn your trust and help with your transition! We’re committed to providing options and ideas that fit each person's priorities...and service afterward as well. If you need anything else, feel free to reach out!"
Ethel Warner
April 21, 2026
"Great staff and service!"
"Thank you for the fantastic review, Ethel! We are glad to hear that Shane Steimel State Farm has provided great service (even after the initial conversations)! We appreciate you trusting us with your home and auto insurance needs - and we look forward to continuing top-level service to your family!"
Sydney Brunk
April 20, 2026
"Shane has been awesome! He’s made it so easy to get quotes, easily explained making sure you’re getting exactly what you want, and in less than 15 minutes my new car has full coverage!"
"Thank you, Sydney, for your fantastic feedback! I'm happy that the explanations were clear and timely to provide you with options that fit your budget! We appreciate helping insure your car and will continue to be here for any questions you might have. Let us know if there's anything else we can do for you!"
Stefanie Stevick
April 16, 2026
"It’s been a pleasure working with Shane, very professional and easy to communicate with. Shows real commitment to his policyholders. Highly recommend to anyone looking for a reliable and personable agent."
"Really appreciate your kind words and review, Stefanie! We are glad to hear that our sincere efforts to serve policyholders shows. Thanks again!"
Ashleigh Engle
March 27, 2026
"Mick has been my agent for years and has always made sure I was taken care of. I just recently had to replace a busted window, and 10 minutes after I called Mick he had a glass company calling me to have it replaced. Took a lot of stress off me knowing it was all taken care of so quickly."
"Thank you so much for sharing your review for us, Ashleigh. We’re thrilled to have your recommendation...and that Mick has been so helpful! We appreciate you choosing the Shane Steimel State Farm office. We'll continue to be here for any questions you might have. Let us know if there's anything else we can do for you!
"
Jennifer Kendig
March 19, 2026
"Great people to work with! Highly recommend."
"Thank you so much for sharing your review for us, Jennifer. We’re thrilled to have your recommendation! We appreciate you choosing the Shane Steimel office and are glad your experiences so far have been positive! We'll continue to be here for any questions you might have. Let us know if there's anything else we can do for you!
"
Tima Ward
March 13, 2026
"Had to update our insurance policy. Spoke with Mick and he was very friendly and helpful and got it done quickly for us. I recommend this office for your insurance needs!"
"Thank you for your great review, Tima! I'm happy to hear that Mick has been friendly and timely when helping with your insurance needs. We truly appreciate your recommendation and are committed to supporting our community with great service. If there's anything else we can do for you, just let us know!"
Miguel Miguel
March 11, 2026
"Great service from Mick at State Farm in Noblesville, IN. They have always taken great care of my wife and I am now transferring all my policies over to them as well. They provide the type of service common people starve for. Not common place for insurance providers and I am Grateful to be on their team."
"Thank you, Miguel, for sharing your thoughts! I'm delighted to hear that Mick has been a great help for you and your wife with your insurance needs. It's wonderful that our desire to provide awesome service has hit the mark, and we appreciate your continued trust. If you have any questions or need assistance with your policies, feel free to reach out. We're here to help!
"
Watch Me Grow Irrigation
March 11, 2026
"Mick is fantastic, he’s on top of everything we throw at him. No hesitation, right to Buisness every time! This State Farm location has consistently done great buisness. They exceeded our expectations on price and performance every-time we insure a new vehicle, trailer or RV with them. Anything we buy that needs insurance from here on will be with Mick and State Farm. Thanks all!"
"Thank you for the terrific review! I'm happy to know that our team's dedication and service have exceeded expectations...and we're thrilled that you're happy with the pricing! Your recommendation means a lot to us. If there's anything else we can assist you with, feel free to reach out anytime!"
Jennifer Carroll
March 10, 2026
"Shane Steimel State Farm in Noblesville, IN has been great to work with. They are very prompt when I leave messages or text for them."
"Jennifer, thank you for your wonderful feedback! I'm happy to hear that our team has been helpful with your questions and concerns - and prompt! We appreciate your trust in us and are glad to be a part of your family's insurance journey. If there's anything else we can do for you, just let us know!
"
Alicia Gebert
March 9, 2026
"Highly recommend working with Shane and his staff! They are always available for your needs and handle things quickly."
"Thank you, Alicia! I'm happy to know that our team's dedication and service have met your expectations. Your recommendation means a lot to us. If there's anything else we can assist you with, feel free to reach out anytime!"
Ryan Hickey
March 7, 2026
"I use State Farm for all of my insurance needs home, auto, and business. Mick has done a great job getting me the coverage I need. When I need documents I receive them in minutes not days. I recommend State Farm."
"Thank you, Ryan, for sharing your thoughts! I'm delighted to hear that Mick has been a great help with your insurance needs. It's wonderful that you find our service so timely, and we appreciate your continued trust. If you have any questions or need assistance with your policies, feel free to reach out. We're here to help!"
Ambria Rankin
February 27, 2026
"Super easy! Gave me everything that I needed and more and made the process super smooth.. Reasonably priced too!"
"Ambria - thank you so much for your 5-star review! We're glad we were able to make it easy for you to get your car insurance...and we're thrilled that the pricing also hit the mark! We appreciate you choosing Shane Steimel State Farm. We'll still be available if you have further questions or concerns. "